• On The Insider: Holy Cleavage!

April 13, 2005 9:40 AM PDT

Start-up claims injunction against Microsoft

Related Stories

Storage industry split over connections

November 27, 2001
A small San Jose, Calif., company said it has been granted a preliminary injunction preventing Microsoft from incorporating a patented networking method into future versions of Windows.

Alacritech said Wednesday that the injunction blocks Microsoft from using its Chimney architecture, which Alacritech said Microsoft plans to include in both a "scalable networking pack" for Windows Server 2003 and in Longhorn, the next version of Windows.

Microsoft's Chimney software provides support for hardware that accelerates networking using the TCP/IP standard, which underlies the Internet and countless private networks. Microsoft designed Chimney to minimize compatibility issues with existing computing technology.

"After Alacritech discovered that Microsoft Chimney is based on intellectual property that we developed, patented and own, we offered Microsoft a license," Alacritech CEO Larry Boucher said in a statement. "Microsoft rejected licensing terms that would be acceptable to us. We were forced to sue Microsoft to stop them from continuing to infringe, and inducing others to infringe, on our intellectual property rights."

Microsoft spokeswoman Stacy Drake reiterated the company's position that its Chimney technology was "independently developed."

"As an intellectual property company, we invest heavily in research and development and are committed to respecting the intellectual property rights of others," Drake said.

Alacritech sued Microsoft last August, alleging that Chimney infringes on two Alacritech patents, both titled "protocol processing stack for use with intelligent network interface device."

According to Alacritech, Microsoft first discussed plans for Chimney at a hardware conference in the spring of 2003. Alacritech said it offered to license its technology to Microsoft that October, but was rebuffed in April 2004, prompting it to file its suit.

An Alacritech representative declined to comment beyond the company's press release.

See more CNET content tagged:
Alacritech Inc., injunction, Stacy Drake, intellectual property right, intellectual property

Add a Comment (Log in or register) 2 comments
So what?
by Konrad April 13, 2005 6:34 PM PDT
The fact that Microsoft indepedently developed its own "chimney" technology is not necessarily a defense. Patent infringement is a strict liability offense, and the lack of knowledge or indepednent development will save Microsoft from willful infringement which carries punitive damages.

Microsoft could have developed an independent chimney technology using processes or technology not covered by this company's patent. This could be true if the process is very narrow.
Reply to this comment
Ditto Independently Developed
by kzetmeir April 14, 2005 4:31 AM PDT
MS may have very well developed a system "independently" ... that doesn't mean others didn't also develop and patent similar works "independently" and earlier than MS. The US system of waiting before any publication of Patent Apps guarantees developers will be working "blind" for some period of time prior to filing their own Application.
advertisement

Latest tech news headlines

RSS Feeds

Add headlines from CNET News to your homepage or feedreader.

More feeds available in our RSS feed index.

Markets

Market news, charts, SEC filings, and more

Related quotes

Microsoft (-6.02%) -1.25 19.51
Dow Jones Industrials (-2.72%) -245.40 8,769.70
S&P 500 (-3.00%) -28.05 906.65
NASDAQ (-3.23%) -53.32 1,599.06
CNET TECH (-3.58%) -42.10 1,133.35
  Symbol Lookup

Inside CNET News

Scroll Left Scroll Right